On the first weekday the Eglinton Crosstown ran, a commuter told CityNews that the ride from Mount Dennis to Avenue took about 30 minutes, where the bus had taken about an hour. Line 5 opened to the public on Sunday, February 8, 2026. At opening, trains ran only until 11 p.m. and signal priority on the surface section was not yet in place, according to TorontoToday. CityNews reported that tunnel speeds were capped during the phased opening.
That half hour saved is worth something, and a buyer comparing Allenby with its neighbours wants to know who is collecting it. Nine months of records suggest the value has gone into one corner lot on Eglinton Avenue West. The detached houses on the streets behind it have not visibly picked it up. Over the past year, the district's house market drew more sellers than buyers, and that changes how a purchase here gets negotiated.
The corner at Castle Knock Road
The clearest evidence of what an Allenby station address is worth sits at 444–466 Eglinton Avenue West, on the northwest corner at Castle Knock Road. UrbanToronto places it a couple of blocks west of Avenue Road and its new Line 5 station.
For this stretch, which the plan calls Eglinton Way, the Yonge–Eglinton Secondary Plan anticipates buildings of 8 storeys, according to a City of Toronto report from October 2024. The applicant first asked for 19 storeys and 185 units, and the proposal later went to the Ontario Land Tribunal at 31 storeys. In its July 2025 interim decision, the Tribunal found 31 storeys too high for the site. The Tribunal's January 30, 2026 decision records that the suitable height had been left open as something "taller than a mid-rise building of eight storeys but lower than 31 storeys." It then continued the hearing on height alone.
In March 2026, City Council adopted settlement directions for a revised scheme by Core Architects for Arista Homes, with heritage oversight by ERA Architects. The revised scheme is 26 storeys, 91.3 metres tall, with 272 condominium units above 442 square metres of retail. UrbanToronto reported that the settlement was headed to the Tribunal for ratification.
The Avenue Road Eglinton Community Association covers the north side of Eglinton from Yonge Street to Chaplin Crescent. In September 2024, it supported mid-rise development on Eglinton Way with a maximum of 8 storeys. The wider rules near the station have also moved. A City status report from September 2025 lists Eglinton West as a Protected Major Transit Station Area and says the Minister's decisions of August 15, 2025 changed its height and density permissions.
On a lot within sight of a station entrance, the step from an anticipated 8 storeys to a settled 26 is the plainest measure of what the station is worth. Land on Eglinton can capture that value through height. A detached house on Elwood or Castle Knock cannot add storeys, so whatever the station adds to its value has to show up in its sale price. That is the next place to look.
What the house market did over the same twelve months
The Toronto Regional Real Estate Board does not publish Allenby on its own. Its monthly figures come by district, and the one used here is C04, which TRREB divides into Bedford Park-Nortown, Englemount-Lawrence, Forest Hill North, Lawrence Park North and Lawrence Park South. The October comparison below sets C04 detached homes against the City of Toronto as a whole, from TRREB's October 2025 and October 2026 Market Watch reports.
| Detached, October | C04, 2025 | C04, 2026 | City of Toronto, 2025 | City of Toronto, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 39 | 42 | 747 | 741 |
| Median price | $2,318,000 | $2,417,500 | $1,245,000 | $1,260,000 |
| Average price | $2,526,621 | $2,731,503 | $1,619,047 | $1,603,886 |
| New listings | 95 | 119 | 1,864 | 1,664 |
| Active listings | 148 | 175 | 2,890 | 2,708 |
| Avg. sale-to-list | 97% | 96% | 98% | 97% |
| Avg. days on market | 17 | 19 | 24 | 24 |
Between October 2025 and October 2026, the C04 detached median rose about 4.3%, while the citywide detached median rose about 1.2%. Across the whole TRREB area, the MLS HPI composite benchmark fell 4.3% over the same twelve months, according to TRREB's October 2026 release. On price alone, C04 looks like a district catching a tailwind.
The listing counts point the other way. Over the same year, C04 new detached listings rose about 25% and active listings about 18%, while sales went from 39 to 42. Citywide, new detached listings fell about 11% and active listings about 6%. Divide each October's active listings by that month's sales: C04 had roughly 3.8 months of supply in October 2025 and roughly 4.2 in October 2026. For the City of Toronto, the same calculation fell from about 3.9 to about 3.7. A year ago C04 was slightly tighter than the city. In October 2026 it was looser. The district's average sale-to-list ratio slipped to 96%, and average days on market rose from 17 to 19.
C04 houses held their prices over the year while more owners chose to sell, and the sale-to-list ratio eased. The median rose because of what sold, and buyers did not have to bid against each other to get there. Rising prices on a thinner sale-to-list ratio usually mean pricier homes made up more of the month's sales. A single month of 42 sales across five communities is easily moved by a few large lots.
Fall listings outnumbered the spring's
The monthly C04 detached figures for 2026 show when the change happened. April had 57 sales against 153 active listings, at a $2,320,000 median. May had 55 sales against 173 active, at a $2,550,000 median. By September, sales had dropped to 37 while active listings reached 181, at a $2,335,000 median. October recovered to 42 sales with 175 active.
In both September and October, C04 carried more active detached listings than it did in April, about 15% more by October, while monthly sales ran well below April's 57. TRREB's chief information officer, Jason Mercer, said in the October release that buyers retained substantial negotiating power across the region. The board pointed to uncertainty over inflation, borrowing costs and the economy as reasons many buyers stayed on the sidelines. In C04, that negotiating power came from a larger pool of houses to choose from, not from falling prices.
Semi-detached homes, a small part of the C04 market, read differently. In October 2026 the district recorded 7 semi sales at a $1,800,000 median and a 99% sale-to-list ratio, against 6 active listings. Seven sales is too few to call a trend, but it is a much tighter month than the district's detached market had.
The street between the tower and the houses
Eglinton Way is where the station's effect and Allenby's house blocks meet, and the street's own calendar this year reflected that. The City says the eglintonTOday streetscape installation between Avenue Road and Chaplin Crescent was completed in fall 2024. The Eglinton Way BIA ran its 2026 farmers' market on Sundays from June 7 to October 25 at the Green P lot at 125 Burnaby Boulevard. Its Artwalk on June 20 included a time capsule ceremony and guided tours of ten sculptures. Dream Wheels filled Eglinton Avenue West from Avenue Road to Castlewood with vintage vehicles and live music on July 25.
Before the opening, Global News spoke with merchants on the strip. Anita Dimitrijevic of Di Moda European Lingerie said she expected more visitors once trains were running. Maureen Sirois, owner of Vicky's Jewellery and president of the Eglinton Way BIA, was optimistic about access and the street's appearance.
How the two stations work in practice also matters to a buyer comparing blocks. UrbanToronto's February review described Avenue's eastern entrance as a stair-heavy climb. It noted that Chaplin has three entrances but no direct connection to the Beltline. In June, a City committee asked Metrolinx to improve wayfinding at Chaplin after riders raised accessibility concerns, CBC Toronto reported. Which entrance is closest to a house tells a buyer more about its transit value than the street's straight-line distance to Eglinton.
Pricing an Allenby house with that in mind
The station's value is clearest at 444–466 Eglinton, where a corner went from an anticipated 8 storeys to a 26-storey settlement. In the detached market, the same period brought a modest price gain and a much larger rise in supply. A seller near the station is entitled to argue for its convenience. A buyer is entitled to see that argument tested against comparable sales, and the C04 numbers do not show houses near the stations clearing at a premium.
For a move-up family comparing Allenby with Lytton Park or Chaplin Estates, that has two practical effects. First, the comparison comes down to the house and the block, because district inventory gives most buyers more than one candidate in a given month. Second, being close to Eglinton now means being close to a corridor where height is being settled one site at a time. That can mean better transit and more shops within walking distance. It can also mean a construction site within sight of the house, depending on which block it is on. October's 96% sale-to-list ratio and 175 active listings suggest buyers had room to weigh both.
TRREB's November figures will show whether the late-year supply held into the winter. Until then, the October report is the most recent read on how many C04 sellers are still in the market.
If you're weighing a house a few blocks from Avenue or Chaplin station, Adam Weiner + Associates can pull the block-level sales behind these district numbers and show what the corner at Castle Knock might mean for your street. Request a concierge consultation, and we'll walk the blocks with you.